Witches Brew Coffee House

Laura

5 months ago

My daughter and I went on a Saturday without a reservation. If you are more than two people DEFINITELY make a reservation! We got very lucky as the hostess was so helpful. We received a table outside in less than five minutes. The atmosphere is exactly what we were hoping for. The servers were all so happy and helpful. Everything came out quickly and was very yummy! Will or sure be going back again!

Mina

3 weeks ago

We finally made it to The Witches Brew and it absolutely lived up to the hype. We ordered a spread: the vegan Korean fried chicken sandwich, Philly cheesesteak, red coconut curry, chocolate cookie à la mode, apple crumb cheesecake, cinnamon bun, and a Boston cream doughnut. First off, the food was outstanding. The vegan Korean fried chicken sandwich was crispy, saucy, and packed with flavor. The Philly cheesesteak was rich and satisfying, the Mac and cheese was rich and gooey, and the red coconut curry had incredible depth with the perfect balance of spice and sweetness. Every savory dish felt thoughtfully made and really comforting. Then came the desserts, which were honestly the highlight. The chocolate cookie à la mode was warm and decadent, the apple crumb cheesecake was unbelievably good, and the cinnamon bun was soft, gooey, and exactly what you want from a bakery-style roll. The only thing that didn’t quite hit the mark for us was the Boston cream doughnut, it was dry to be honest, but with how incredible everything else was, it barely mattered. The staff were also incredibly sweet and friendly, which made the whole experience even better. Between the creative menu, the quality of the food, and the cozy atmosphere, this place is such a gem. We’ll definitely be back to try more of the menu.

Trisha T

5 months ago

VIBES I've been going to the Witches Brew since about 2008 and it's still one of my favorite cozy spots. The decor is spooky and a little eclectic. While during the day you can see the fun mixed and matched vintage furniture, at night their warm string lights make for the coziest ambiance. It's especially perfect during the Halloween season. One thing that I noticed from our most recent visit on a Friday evening is there were a good amount of families with kids and even babies. It might be quieter to go at a different time like I have in the past. Funny enough, it's probably all the people like me who used to come here in our high school days. SERVICE They get super busy and have implemented a virtual waiting list system that you can find via a link on their Instagram. It'll notify you when you're next and gives you 10 minutes to get back there. Honestly, easy nicer than waiting in a line outside in the cold! They've also always had super nice servers that regardless of time have the same friendly chill vibes. FOOD My favorite thing to get here is one of their special coffee flavors. They have a huge assortment with fun spooky names. I love picking one with a marshmallow flavor base. Might be called Midnight. They also have a huge adjustment of loose leaf teas that they serve in cast iron tea pots. These drinks pair perfectly with their desserts. My favorite things to get from them is a warm cinnamon bun a la mode. For their savory food it should be noted that the whole menu is vegetarian/vegan friendly. Something we ALWAYS get is their focaccia which is warm and cheesy. Their artichoke dip with nachos is excellent and my husband enjoyed his falafel sandwich with fries.

Samiha Rahman

4 months ago

Adorable and cozy vibes here. Surprisingly a good amount of options for food and coffee. Beautifully dim lit, great for a date night or an intimate time with friends. You can tell it’s a neighborhood spot. Decor was beautiful. Perfect for the fall. Food was decent, vegan only. CHAI FREEZE WAS AMAZING. Service was pretty good, the staff are straightforward. CASH ONLY. ‼️JOIN THE WAITLIST BEFORE COMING‼️

Cindy Benitez

5 months ago

not ashamed of the amount of times i come here, it’s my go to spot. i love that they change the menu every few months based on what’s in season, until i love something so much and they don’t have it . it’s crazy that they say they are vegan cause you would’ve fooled me but i love variety and man do they have options! the coffee the tea the pastries the food and the atmosphere really do make this place what it is . the service is always so welcoming and friendly. the decor is what got me as soon as i walked in the first time, whimsical goth laid back and cozy . i couldn’t find all the pictures ive taken of my times there but there will be more to come !

Spaxed

3 months ago

The service was amazing, they answer any question you have politely, and the waiter helps you with recommendations for what to get. The food was some of the best I’ve had, I wanted more even when I was full, and so many things are organic and all are vegan are vegetarian, which is great because there aren’t any vegan spots that are this good on Long Island. The coffee was so good too, some of the best I’ve had, and there’s so many unique syrups. The atmosphere is very cozy on the inside and out, it definitely stands out on the street It’s located on. 10/10, I’ll definitely be coming back

Tulika

5 months ago

What a unique and magical place! The location is absolutely beautiful and so thoughtfully designed. We were pleasantly surprised to find that it’s a fully vegan spot with such an impressive variety of drinks and food options. We tried the Pesto Gnocchi, Smokey Tea, and Mocha Coffee — everything was delicious! The brownie cheesecake was mouthwatering and a must-try. The only downsides were the long wait time and the reservation process, even on a Friday afternoon.. Also, I felt the service could be a bit more attentive. Also, the automatic 20% gratuity for a party of two was unexpected. That said, the ambience was absolutely amazing — cozy, creative, and full of character. Totally worth the visit, and I can’t wait to go back! 🌿☕✨

Ava Ange

3 months ago

Amazing food, even my boyfriend who isnt vegan/vegetarian, loved his food. He loves fried chicken normally but wouldnt stop raving about how good the vegan fried chicken sandwich was. Im fully vegan and I got the coconut curry as well as trying his sandwich and both were exceptionally good. Fries were so so good too. The coffee is VERY good. As a vegan its hard to find good coffee but this place offeres many syrup options as well as vegan whipped cream and alternative milks. I got hazelnut vanilla and maple syrups oatmilk latte and it was so good and rich and smooth, not too sweet but definitely not bitter. My boyfriend got the French vanilla and marshmallow syrups with oatmilk and vegan whipped cream and said its the best whipped cream hes ever tried, again hes not vegan and a big sweet lover. Also our waitress was so kind and helpful when answering my questions. Staff seems happy and welcoming despite being insanely busy. Will definitely be coming back every time im in town. 10/10 restruant.

Diana DeLeon (DD)

3 weeks ago

Everything we tried was delicious. I've never had a vegan chicken that good. Heres what we got: Frozen vanilla Chai drink, frozen chocolate drink, buffalo cauliflower, Mac and cheese, Korean fried chicken sandwich, chicken marsala, mushroom Alfredo pasta, apple crumb cheesecake, brownie cheesecake and sugar free apple pie. Our waiter was super nice and very attentive. The restaurants atmosphere was great too. Looking forward to our next visit!!

Reana R

Edited 3 weeks ago

If you know, you KNOW. Witches Brew is the spot for delicious food, amazing drinks, decadent desserts and the coziest vibes. Everything is completely vegan, but you would never feel like you’re missing a thing. The flavors are comforting and so satisfying. I always have to start with the nachos. My longtime go-to is the falafel sandwich (so good every single time), but I recently tried the pesto gnocchi and wow… that might be my new favorite. Absolute perfection. I just had their hot cocoa with peanut butter added and it is officially my favorite hot cocoa ever. Rich, cozy, and exactly what you want in a warm drink. This place just feels special. I’ve been coming here for years with my friends. Forever a favorite.